IV
Graham remained at Dillon Beach for a few more weeks. The weather had grown gray once again, as the fog shrouded the shore. He finished the book, determined to leave behind both California and the memory of Anna. Soon after submitting his manuscript, he packed his bags and returned to New York. He texted his wife when he arrived at the airport and again after boarding the plane. He turned his phone off before takeoff and turned it back on a few hours later after landing in Newark International Airport. No notifications appeared when he repowered it.
He took the train into New York. His shoulders slumped forward as he watched the terminal fade behind him through the window. When he arrived at the station, he took the subway north and walked the three blocks to his and his wife’s apartment. The stairway that led to their unit felt unending as he climbed the four flights. Unlocking the door, he was greeted by his wife’s black and white cat, who he secretly loathed. His wife returned after sunset.
Greeting him with a cold indifference, she passed him as he sat on the couch. She closed the door to their bedroom behind her. He knew better than to follow her. Remaining on the couch, he watched old episodes of Seinfeld before drifting to sleep.
He awoke the next morning to the sound of her making coffee. She poured him a mug, placing it on the table before him.
“Thank you,” he said softly, still acclimating to the early morning.
“You’re welcome,” she said. “Welcome home.”
He checked his phone to find no notifications. Gravity seemed to intensify, pulling his shoulders toward the hardwood floor. The cat climbed onto the coffee table and hovered over the rising steam. Graham brushed the cat off the table, but it quickly climbed back up. Taking the mug into his hand, he sank further into the beaten leather couch. His wife left for work a few moments later, leaving Graham with only the cat to keep him company.
Once he had finished his coffee, he grabbed his laptop and walked to his favorite diner. The cold air outside bit at his cheeks as he tucked his chin into his fleece. At the diner, which stood mostly empty, he ordered another coffee and two eggs with bacon and hash browns. While he waited for his food, he pulled out his laptop and began browsing for his next project. He searched the listings until the waitress, dressed in a white apron, dropped a plate of eggs before him.
For weeks, he continued visiting the diner to eat eggs and search for work. He heard back about another ghostwritten memoir, but felt little interest in returning west. After deliberating, he decided to write them back and declined the offer, despite its high pay.
When his wife asked about the job search, he said that he had arranged a meeting with a prospective client in Philadelphia, although no client existed. He bought an Amtrak ticket from New York to Philadelphia, departing at the end of the week.
The days filled with increasing anxiety as his departure date drew closer. With no real plan to find Anna beyond putting his faith in chance, he packed a suitcase and hoped to run into her. The idea felt crazier with each day. Millions of people live in Philadelphia. The chance of running into Anna felt impossible. He kept considering canceling his ticket, but ultimately decided not to. After an indifferent farewell from his wife, he walked to the subway to make his way to Penn Station.
Arriving at the station early, he waited on a long wooden bench beside the ticket counter. Crowds of people filtered in and out of the terminal on their way to and from the tracks. Some stopped at the shops that lined the walls. A long line formed in front of the coffee stand as tired travelers eagerly awaited their caffeine fix. He watched as people ordered and gathered at the other end of the counter.
His mind drifted to Anna. Was he crazy for going? Would she even want to see him? He tried convincing himself to go back, but could not reconcile his heart with reason.
An older man came and sat next to him on the bench. “Where are you heading?” he asked.
“Philly,” Graham said, only glancing in his direction for a brief second.
“A short trip. What brings you there?”
“I’ve been asking myself that all week.” He thought for a moment. “Hope.”
“Hope? Odd place to look for that.”
Graham laughed. “You’re probably right.”
With a nod, Graham left the bench and made his way onto the platform. His train soon arrived. He boarded and tucked his suitcase into the overhead compartment. The train began moving a few moments after he had settled into his window seat. His head leaned against the glass as they sped through the seemingly endless network of tunnels.
Suddenly, light poured through the window, blinding him as the train emerged from the city with trees and tall grass now lining the rails.
They first stopped in Trenton, where Graham briefly contemplated getting off, before arriving at Jefferson Station in Philadelphia. It was late afternoon by the time Graham left the station and walked the cold city streets to his hotel a few blocks away. After checking in, he dropped off his bag in his room, before finding a nearby bar to drink Yuengling and think of a plan for the coming week. The bar was mostly full by the time he finished his first beer. The 76ers were about to play against the Knicks. Graham did his best to contain his fandom given the hostile nature of Philadelphia sports fans.
He drank a few more beers, staying at the bar for the entire game, before buying dinner from the halal truck outside and returning to the hotel to eat in his room. After eating, he found that he couldn’t sleep, so he went out for a cocktail.
The bar was mostly empty, but he stayed and drank his margarita before paying in cash and heading back to the hotel. The cold air of the city night bit at the exposed half of his face as he tucked his chin into his fleece. Back in the hotel, he found sleep quickly.
He awoke early the next morning and went out to buy a cup of coffee. For days, he continued to roam around the city, visiting different shops and bars in the hopes of running into Anna. Each time, he stepped into an establishment filled with hope, and each time he left feeling more foolish than before. One day, feeling especially futile, he even took a historical tour of the city. To his surprise, he actually enjoyed the tour, but it did little to hearten him. With only a day left in his trip and almost all hope lost, he decided to visit Reading Terminal Market for lunch.
Wandering aimlessly through the market, he admired the different stands as he strolled through the crowded aisles. Eventually, he stopped to buy a cheesesteak. While waiting for his food, he saw Anna holding hands with a slender man. Her face disappeared quickly into the sea of people. Graham followed in her direction, forgetting all about his order.
Eventually, he found her again, standing next to the man, whose shoulders slouched slightly forward, in line for a gyro. Graham stopped quickly at the fish market and hoped that they had not noticed him. He hid near the salmon for a moment.
“How are you?” asked the woman behind the fish counter.
“I’m just looking.” He glanced at Anna and the man, who were now sitting at the counter of the gyro shop. Graham turned back to the cashier. “Thanks.” He retreated further from them to the Amish candy shop.
“Hello,” said a woman wearing a white bonnet. “Would you like to try some fudge?”
Graham thought about it for a second.
“Sure,” he said. He took the small sample loosely wrapped in paper. He gazed toward them again as he popped the small fudge square into his mouth.
“That might be the best fudge I’ve ever had!”
“Thank you!”
“I’ll take half a pound.” Smiling, he gave the woman cash. She returned his change before cutting and weighing a block of fudge. She wrapped it in parchment paper and handed it to him. Taking the fudge from her, he turned toward the Gyro stand and saw Anna sitting alone. He approached her. When he was only a few steps away, she turned and looked at him. His heartbeat fell out of rhythm. She turned pale.
“Hello,” he said.
“What are you doing here?” she asked. She glanced quickly over her shoulder to see if her husband was nearby.
“I had to see you. Please.”
“My husband will be back any second.” She looked over her shoulder again. “You have to get out of here.”
“I know. I shouldn’t have come.”
Her gaze softened. “I am so unhappy here.” She sighed. “I wish we were still on the beach…but you have to leave. Please! I promise I will come to New York!”
They touched their phones together to exchange contact information before Graham turned and fled.